Wednesday, 8 April 2015

Review - Haifa Fragments

This is the first book review I’ve done on this blog.  I’ve shied away from reviewing books here because I do so much of it elsewhere and Charlotte’s is a space I’ve given myself to ruminate on all kinds of subjects, where I can follow my own quirks and obsessions rather than accommodating an editor’s. 

But Haifa Fragments is a special book, a novel set as the title suggests in Haifa, a city where I spent time a while back, on a subject that has been dear to my heart for over a quarter of a century. 

 In 1922 my grandfather’s sister left what was then Bessarabia for Palestine, where she joined the G’dud Ha’Avodah or Labor Legion, a roving socialist collective that did much to further the Zionist colonisation of Palestine by building a network of roads between the Jewish settlements and taking part in the development of Tel Aviv.  But my great-aunt, like others in the G’dud, which at one time numbered something like 15,000 Zionist ‘pioneers’, woke up to what they were doing and formed a Communist faction instrumental in mounting a fierce opposition to the mainstream Zionist project.  For this the G’dud was not only ostracised but members of the faction were jailed by the British and eventually deported to the Soviet Union.

My great-aunt’s story excited me because it demonstrated that Zionism might have taken a different turn, one that could have avoided much of the hatred and heartache that’s followed.  In short, a Jewish homeland in Palestine need not have been the Jewish state that Theodor Herzl and his followers desired, but a significant presence in a polity where Palestinians participated on an equal basis.  It gave me a clue to a solution for the mess we have now, the ongoing discrimination perpetrated by Israel against its Palestinian citizens and the horrific injustices it inflicts on Palestinians in the Occupied Territories.  It seemed from studying the history that what was always needed was a single state, neither Jewish nor Palestinian, but embracing the cultures and rights of these two peoples.  And indeed there were Zionists who advocated this all along, but these were effectively silenced, especially after events in Europe took their catastrophic turn. 

Today, over 70 years after the Holocaust, and given the current hostilities, it’s probable that such a state could only evolve from a federation of three states - say, Israel, Jordan and the Palestinian one, once it gets off the ground.  This is the scenario Israeli activist Jeff Halper advocates. This could be a slow, difficult and sadly bloody process, but it’s the only one that, to my mind, makes sense.  One state, encompassing the three nationalities and building on their combined strength, which could be a welcome bulwark for peace in the region.  There are those, like Miko Peled and others, who point out that, taken as a totality, Israel is a single binational state already, albeit one that is predicated on a brutal form of apartheid.

How do ordinary people go about their lives in such a situation?  This is exactly the question that Khulud Khamis, the author of this intricately faceted gem of a novel, has chosen to address.  Maisoon, her protagonist, is a young Palestinian woman from a Christian family, one of those that defiantly remained inside Israel after Zionists unilaterally declared an independent state and expelled two-thirds of the Palestinian population.  While daily confronted with the consequences of this event - the Nakba - and Israel's occupation of what had been Syrian, Egyptian and Jordanian territories that came in 1967, Maisoon’s parallel quest is for independence as an artist and a woman.  Her boyfriend Ziyad, a Muslim, finds her both fascinating and unfathomable.  He would marry her though he expects her parents would oppose it.  Marriage, however, is the last thing Maisoon is aiming for.  To be as resigned as her mother? As accommodating as her father?  Yet how does a Palestinian woman cut a genuine path for herself with so many social, political and cultural obstacles in the way?

Haifa is both an Arab and Jewish city and, as would happen, Maisoon has two Jewish friends.  One, Tamar, is a member of the Jewish women’s protest group Machsom Watch.  These are the women who stand witness to what Israeli soldiers routinely dish out to Palestinians forced to wait at the many checkpoints dotting the occupied West Bank.  It is through Tamar that Maisoon meets Shadh, who lives in a refugee camp and regularly risks her life by sneaking across the border into Israel.  With dreams of her own she feels can never be realised, Shadh soon falls in love with determinedly free-spirited Maisoon.

Maisoon lives alone in a dilapidated flat in the Arab section of the city.  Ziyad is a frequent visitor, that's all.  For Maisoon, the flat serves as both statement and sanctuary.  It is also her studio, where she designs and makes jewellery.  Her days are consumed in developing the right patterns and colours for her creations, the striking bracelets, rings, necklaces and earrings.  An old woman arranges for Maisoon to show them to Amalia, who owns a boutique in Haifa’s fashionable Hadar district.  After a slow start Amalia becomes Maisoon's business mentor, while Maisoon's distinctive jewellery comes to be the boutique’s principal drawcard, with the promise of export sales and a truly independent future for Maisoon.

So there you have it.  So many aspects of Haifa, Israel’s most multicultural, multifaceted city.   Arabs and Jews, Muslims and Christians, artists and business people and many like Ziyad, who see no real prospect for advancement.  Maisoon’s sexuality too is a sharp break from the traditional accommodation represented by her parents.  In the confines of Haifa, then, Khamas depicts in microcosm present-day Israeli society.   

But where is the back story, the history?  Maisoon has another quest, not for the future but the past.  She tries to make sense of a cache of her father’s old letters, brimming with poetry and passion, letters he wrote when he was young.  Now in middle age, Majid seems subdued and distant, nothing like the fiery, romantic youth who comes across in these fragments. As parents generally appear to their adult children, Maisoon’s seem so much smaller than they once had been, with much of life seeming to have been hammered out of them.  But as she struggles to carve out that different path for herself, what is revealed of her father's suffering leads to a fuller understanding of the depth of the Nakba’s impact and its decades-long after shocks, on her family and, ultimately, herself.

What can the future hold for Maisoon and women like her?  What is the future for Israel?  No doubt it has already become the Spartan state Hannah Arendt, for one, had warned it would. And what could be the place of Palestinians living within its borders if a Palestinian state ever eventuates?  Will Maisoon and others like her be ‘transferred’ across the border, to be uprooted  again?  What amount of blood will be spilled before these questions can be answered?  Sensibly, Khamis makes no attempt to answer them.  It is enough that she has left us to pose them.


  1. thank you Sara for this wonderful review that connects the dots between fiction and reality.

  2. My pleasure, Khulud. Your book is a fine achievement and I loved reading it.

  3. Hmm ... the notify me check box has disappeared again, so I may not notice if you reply to this.

    Anyhow, beautiful review Sara. You are clearly the person to review this book, with your longterm knowledge of and interest in the topic. I learnt a lot as well as becoming intrigued about this particular novel. I love the idea of a child finding out about her parents earlier life. Sad that so often life seems to be hammered out of people, particularly if theirs have been tough. Anyhow, Spinifex publishes some excellent books.

  4. Thanks for your comment, WG. Sorry I didn't answer sooner but I was tied up. And yes, the Blogger system has its problems and I really haven't got on top of them myself. And yes, too, the Spinifex list is a fine one.

  5. Academic essay writing has been a parameter to judge the merits of the students for a long time. The present time is none the less. In fact, as time is passing by, students are having more and more requirements to write an essay that will be graded. Hence seeking do my essay help is on the rise and it will be. You should choose best and cheap essay writing services.

  6. Any good book should adhere to those criteria according to which you will evaluate it. You can learn more about it by availing our evaluative essay writing help. The hand-picked persuasive essay writers of are here to help you out. Would you like to burn the midnight oil to write the essay, or enjoy a sound sleep while we take care of your essay worries? We have 500+ highly qualified writers on board. They hail from the field of academics and are well-versed with the complications involved in writing an analytical essay help.

  7. IdealAssignmentHelp is also one of the best and most reliable names in the business who can help you with your need for assignment writing tasks. If Anyone Want My Assignment Help Then contact our expert team we have here providing Assignment Help for Australian Students with Affordable prices.

  8. Everything should be based on fact. The arrangement of fact and information is not an easy task sometimes it becomes a very tough task to do in such cases student can go through online My Assignment Help , and these services are very reliable, and they can provide information about any topic related to the academics. If you need any college level Assignment Help at reliable quality with better work. Kindly visit our website.

  9. Excellent information Providing by your Article, thank you for taking the time to share with us such a nice article. Amazing insight you have on this, it's nice to find a website that details so much information about different artists. Kindly visit the LiveWebTutors website we providing the best assignment help services in Australia.

    For More Info: Assignment Writing Help

  10. I recommend that everyone should seek assistance from Assignment Help Australia for the best academic help. There are professional experts from various esteemed universities in almost every field. They are capable to write the premium quality of assignments according to the requirements of students and university norms.

  11. Thanks for taking the time to discuss this, I feel strongly about it and love learning more on this topic. If possible, as you gain expertise, would you mind updating your blog with more information? It is extremely helpful for me.

    Mathematics Assignment help

    Architecture assignment help

    Biotechnology assignment help

    Economics Homework help

    Computer science assignment help

  12. I will tell you about Haifa Fragments, a good book. Haifa Fragments is a book about jewellery designer and has much knowledge for its readers. I have read it many a time. I hope, you will understand about Haifa Fragments. Cheap dissertation writing service.